Showing posts with label Teaching AI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Teaching AI. Show all posts

Thursday, April 2, 2026

Educators Need to Teach True AI and Technology Literacy

Should we be afraid of AI? If you listen to the Seers of Silicon Valley, we should be shaking in our boots. AI is going to displace us in our jobs; turn us into Duracel batteries; and turn us into gurgling, nonthinking imbeciles, sitting in our homes with technology waiting on us hand and foot.

Not true. Besides, our Seers have gotten much wrong in the past, so why would we expect the Bill Gateses, Alex Karps, or Sam Altmans of the world to have access to anything that resembles our future? Besides, their wealth and future is entirely dependent upon the fate of their now favorite technology. That has always been the case.

My real concern here is not with their self-serving prognosticating nonsense, but with what we as educators should be doing if we really give a damn about what is being called “AI Literacy.” 

As a part of “AI Literacy” we should be teaching students the real function of these stories and to see them for what they really are and do. For starters:

1-They make it seem like there is only one possible direction for the development of AI, their chosen route. Not so.

2-We are powerless to do anything about it, and must accept the AI they have provided for us. Not really.

3-They purposely hide who is really going to win and benefit from AI; which includes them and all the minions and bottomfeeders gathering the scraps that fall from their table.

4-The Seers prevent any public debate about their version of AI, and curtail any questioning of the goods they are delivering. That’s Silicon Valley marketing tactics at their best.

5-They also prevent any questioning of the massive resource shift (water, power, minerals, human resources) to their benefit at the expense of everyone else. They are stealing resources for their own wealthy gain.

If we are going to teach students anything about AI, it should be to teach them critical thinking instead of turning AI into an object of worship. We did that with the PC, the Web, and social media, and are reaping the results.

All technology literacy needs to teach students about all aspects of every technology we use.

As an educator, our responsibility is not to generate unquestioning users and consumers for the products developed by the Seers of Silicon Valley. 

Our responsibility should transcend making students consumers of technology; it should be empowering them to shape the future with or without technologies. This is done by giving them the gift of critically analyzing what the Seers are saying and not saying.

At least by doing that, we keep our students from becoming the tools of the technologies they use. 

That’s AI literacy, Technology literacy at its best!


Sunday, June 29, 2025

The Promo-Rhetoric of Silicon Valley Infiltrate's Bowen and Watson's book "Teaching with AI"

I read Jose Bowen and C. Edward Watson's book "Teaching with AI: A Practical Guide to a New Era of Human Learning" because I noticed a few plugs for the tome on social media and I am intensely interested in this new fad called "Teaching with AI."

What immediately struck me about this book is that it immediately engages in the Silicon Valley tactic of short-circuiting the debate of whether AI should be used in teaching at all with the so-called "inevitability argument." This is the Valley's perfect marketing tactic that was employed by social media companies and technology companies when they hawked their products in the 2000s.

The truth is we do not need to accept uncritically this "inevitability argument" when it comes to AI. We can not only simply choose not to use it as teachers, we can ask tough questiosn about it, such as what are the possible negative consequences in engaging this technology in our classrooms.

Choosing not to use it is an option and refusing to accept the Silicon Valley inevitability argument is perfectly rational. The world isn't going to leave us behind in caves trying to start fires by rubbing two sticks together. Choosing not to use it is not a detrimental choice; it can be a critical, thoughtful and moral choice.

What Bowen and Watson's book gets wrong is not all of its attempts to get teachers to use Silicon Valley's latest offering. What it gets terribly wrong is that we have no choice but to use AI.

We can, however, refuse and critically question the promo-rhetoric that these authors engage in. I would expect teachers who really want to engage students in the most worthy of learning would do no less that engage students in thinking critically about whether engaging in its use is inevitable.